Monday, June 20, 2016

Paul Hetzler: Pining For The Good Old Days

Adirondack Rain StormEver find yourself pining away for the “good old days” when things were simpler, a time when 911 was just a number, and no one was allergic to peanut butter? Maybe you like the era of Beatles concerts, big collars and even bigger hair, or you dream of living in the horse-and- buggy days.

Personally, I get misty-eyed when I think back to the early 2000s. It’s not that I can’t remember further back—my memory isn’t quite that bad yet. But those were the good old days when you could grow tomatoes free of blight, and pine needles were green. (Have you taken a look at the eastern white pines and Scots pines this summer? I’m pretty sure yellow and brown are not their normal colors.) Plant diseases have really blossomed recently.

Food allergies and terrorism have complex and varied causes, and I don’t pretend to understand their origins. But the mushrooming of plant diseases over the past 15 years or so is not hard to explain. In a word, it now stays too wet for too long during the growing season. (OK, that’s twelve words—so there goes my credibility.) Why is this happening? It has a lot to do with our changed weather patterns.

Before everyone sprints toward the ranks of their respective teams in the Climate-Change Smackdown Series, please note I have not used any of those bad four-letter words like warming or global or climate (until this sentence, that is). I’m talking about simple weather-station readings taken in northern NY between 1970 and today. This area now gets at least three more inches of precipitation per year than it did back then.

So it rains a little more than it used to—is that the problem? Well, partly. You’ve probably noticed how it seems as if we’ve been enrolled in a Weather-of- the-Month Club in recent years. As a current example, the latter half of April and the entire month of May were practically rain-free. Then the Weather Club sent us a new flavor, and it has barely dried out once during the first two weeks of June.

Since this trend first came to my attention in 2005, most summers (2012 was a notable exception) have included blocks ranging from 20 to 25 consecutive days of measurable rainfall. This did not used to happen. Diseases which once caused occasional mild symptoms in the “good old days” now kill trees and devastate gardens. In fact, tomato diseases were so bad in 2013 (a virtual monsoon year) that the plant-disease folks at Cornell were wondering if new, more potent strains of common pathogens like septoria spot had emerged. Conclusion: it was just the weather.

To compound the situation, drought stress has weakened trees across the board (so to speak), reducing their ability to resist disease. Plant pathologist Dr. George Hudler of Cornell notes that the frequency and severity of drought events has increased markedly beginning in about 1980. Dr. Hudler further states that it can take from two to three years for a tree to fully recover from a single five-week dry spell. The problem is that trees often do not get a chance to regain their vigor before another such event hits them, leading to a chronic-stress driven downward spiral.

This year, pines throughout New England have “suddenly” turned brown in large numbers. Along roadsides where deicing salt spray drifts onto tree branches, it’s not unusual to see some brown needles come spring. But this year, even forest trees look bad. While some biologists and foresters saw this at low levels a few years ago, it is now widespread.

The Cornell Plant Pathology Lab has had more evergreen-related calls, emails and samples than usual this spring, but so far no single “bad guy” pathogen has emerged as the culprit. Rather it seems that a cadre of normally-weak fungal agents may be involved. The lab has also found a few insect pests on submitted samples, but at levels too low to explain the death of needles. It is frustrating to not have an answer yet, but a lot of people are working to solve the mystery.

Spruces have also taken a beating in the past ten to twenty years. It is normal for lower branches to die as they become shaded out, but on many spruces, needles have been dropping throughout the crown, leaving patches of gray where whole branches have died. While in the past this might happen in cases of overcrowding or on sites that were too shady, today even trees in the open are affected.

It’s good to know that some spruces are more disease resistant than others. Without a doubt, the most vulnerable is the one arborists call Colorado spruce (Picea pungens), known to normal people as blue spruce. Though it is valued for its blue-green color as well as for its deer resistance, it is not the best choice. The ideal location for a blue spruce is on an arid mountain in Colorado. They really aren’t cut out for the Northeast.

Norway spruce appears to be the most disease resistant, and white spruce is somewhere in between. In addition to species selection, planting evergreens farther apart in sunny locations with good air circulation can also help minimize disease. Where possible, water your trees, even mature ones, during dry spells to help keep them healthy.

Seriously, I do miss the good old days. But I’ll try not to pine away excessively. For more information, including how to submit samples to the plant lab for diagnosis, please contact your local Cornell Cooperative Extension office.


Related Stories

Paul Hetzler has been an ISA Certified Arborist since 1996. His work has appeared in the medical journal The Lancet, as well as Highlights for Children Magazine.You can read more of his work at or by picking up a copy of his book Shady Characters: Plant Vampires, Caterpillar Soup, Leprechaun Trees and Other Hilarities of the Natural World

4 Responses

  1. Charlie S says:

    We’re discouraged to mention the words ‘global warming’ because it makes some of us uneasy due to insecurities or because we’re afraid of change. We refuse to admit,or even acknowledge,that the earth is warming up and so we go about our affairs with the earth like we always do…roughshod and mindless. 2015 was a record warm year for planet earth. It broke the 2014 record and every year we set new records yet nothing changes. We keep building more roads or there’s talks about building more roads and all of this blacktop and pavement and concrete that we call parking lots or shopping centers or whatever it is we keep adding to the concrete jungle…these are surely adding warmth to this planet. The mindless people who leave their engines running while their cars are parked! Surely they must be adding to the rise in the mercury…..that is if it is true that carbon emissions are the culprit. We really don’t know for sure. I mean it could be cyclic or it could be human stupidity but still…. THE EARTH IS WARMING UP HELLO! All the trees we take down cannot be helping natters. I’m of the mind we should preserve every living thing that remains.

    You’d think there would be a collective concern on the matter but ‘No’ it’s just pockets of thoughtful people who seem to be pushed aside as alarmist environmentalists by the do-nothing bunch which is quite a large assemblage by the way. It seems to me we’d rather run towards the flames than run towards the fire escape.

  2. Paul Hetzler says:

    Charlie, I agree with you entirely. Being in the horticulture field, I constantly see new examples of how stressed the ecosystem is. It’s disheartening.

    The reason for my wording in the article is to point out there is pure and simple evidence that long-term weather patterns (i.e. climate) have changed, even if one doesn’t believe in the concept of human-induced climate change.

    It is sad how the terms climate change and global warming cause some folks to turn off their brains and turn on their hostility. Anger is always a cover for fear; it’s a way not to acknowledge or feel it.

    • Boreas says:

      I believe the problem is that many people allow their news and information sources to do the thinking for them – which can work both ways. People no longer take the time to think critically. News media has changed from simply presenting unbiased fact to opinion disguised as fact. News media is now largely an opinion column in a newspaper (if anyone remembers what they are). Then radio & TV “entertainers” take it to the next level and create fear and mistrust.24/7 news cycles drums this drivel into people’s heads – the simplest form of brainwashing. It is like being raised in a bigoted family – one is likely to become a bigot themselves.

      Only until money and politics are removed from news media will people be able to think for themselves again.

  3. Charlie S says:

    It ‘is’ disheartening Paul and it’s too bad because future generations are going to pay dearly for the thoughtlessness that is so prevalent in today’s society.

Wait! Before you go:

Catch up on all your Adirondack
news, delivered weekly to your inbox