Wednesday, January 23, 2019

John W. Taylor: New York’s (Almost Only) Speaker of the House

The title Speaker of the House of Representatives has received lots of attention during the past few years. It’s hard to believe that the nation’s fourth-most-populous state (New York—nearly always number one, and in the top five since 1790) has only one native who served in that position.

Well, technically, there are two, but one of them served 99.82 percent of the pair’s total time in office—to be explained later. If you’re from Northern New York and dislike the idea of people owning people, you’ll be pleased at his strong stance for freedom during one of our nation’s most turbulent times.

The man of the House is John W. Taylor, born in the town of Ballston Spa in 1784. (In 1791, when Saratoga County was created, his birthplace ended up in the town of Charlton.) Taylor enrolled at Union College in Schenectady at age 15, and graduated in 1803 as a 19-year-old valedictorian. He married Jane Hodge in 1806 (they would have eight children together), began studying law, and was admitted to the bar four years later. During the next several years, the Taylors lived at Hadley Landing (today’s Corinth), where he became a partner in a lumber business while serving as postmaster and town clerk.

He was elected to the New York State Legislature in 1811, where strong debating skills won him leadership positions. Against banks seeking power through illegal means, and even against his own party’s recommendations, he stood unflinchingly against corruption, revealing a level of integrity much admired by voters. As a well-deserved result, he was reelected, but before completion of his second term, voters sent Taylor to the House of Representatives in Washington, where he began serving in spring 1813.

His upbringing, education, religious ethics, and his father’s public service, helped mold Taylor into a capable, dedicated, and trusted public representative. For several years he acquitted himself well, was popular at Washington social events (including White House functions), and was respected enough by his colleagues to be appointed the second-ever House Whip (then an unofficial but important position).

The question of slavery — specifically, the question of whether slavery should be allowed in territories and new states — thrust Taylor into the national spotlight in the years before 1820. Missouri was about to gain statehood, and John W. Taylor, along with fellow New York representatives James Tallmadge and Rufus King, led the fight to ban slavery there. Pro-slavery legislators were outraged when the Tallmadge Amendment was proposed, mandating, among other things, “that the further introduction of slavery or involuntary servitude be prohibited” in Missouri.

Speaker of the House Henry Clay of South Carolina argued that, for several reasons, the amendment should be withdrawn. Taylor’s response included an uncanny prediction about the terrible war that would follow 40 years later, noting that instead of solving the issue, Clay’s proposal to continue allowing slavery “saves a finger today, but amputates the arm tomorrow.”

After proposing the amendment, Tallmadge fell ill, leaving Taylor to fill the void. In doing so, he did not shy from debate. In a 1819 speech before the House, he criticized southern lawmakers who frequently voiced their dismay that slavery was entrenched and necessary to their existence.

“How often, and how eloquently, have they deplored its existence among them?,” said Taylor, “What willingness … have they not manifested to be relieved from this burden? How have they wept over the unfortunate policy that first introduced slaves into this country! How have they disclaimed the guilt and shame of that original sin, and thrown it back upon their ancestors!”

“Gentlemen have now an opportunity of putting their principles into practice. If they have tried slavery and found it a curse; if they desire to dissipate the gloom with which it covers their land; I call upon them to exclude it from the Territory in question; plant not its seeds in this uncorrupt soil; let not our children, looking back to the proceedings of this day, say … ‘we wish their decision had been different.’”

Southerners, Taylor said, “regretted” slavery, but blamed their ancestors for establishing a dark tradition that powered the South’s economic engine. Unlike northerners, epitomized by elbow grease and a hands-on attitude, southerners considered manual labor demeaning, something best performed by their inferiors, slaves. Reinforcing that concept, said Taylor, was the fact that nearly all public offices in the South were held by slave owners. He even brought that argument to the floor of Congress while noting his own rejection of any system “rendering labor disgraceful.”

“When have we seen a Representative on this floor from that section of our Union who was not a slaveholder?,” he said. “Who but slaveholders are elected to their State legislatures? Who but they are appointed to fill their executive and judicial offices?” He added that “the selection of a laboring man, however well educated” would be “an extraordinary event.”

Taylor further warned that Missouri’s fate would “decide the destiny of millions” in future states to the north and west. “Our votes this day will determine whether the high destinies of this region, and of these generations, shall be fulfilled, or whether we shall defeat them by permitting slavery, with all its baleful consequences, to inherit the land.”

The amendment passed in the House but then failed in the Senate. The outcome was the Missouri Compromise: slavery was allowed in Missouri, but not in the other new state, Maine, and was banned in the future from north of the 36°30′ parallel.

In October 1820, after guiding the Missouri Compromise towards passage, Henry Clay resigned as Speaker of the House. John Taylor, a House veteran of seven years, ran for the office on three issues, including opposition to extending slavery into territories and new states. His opponent from South Carolina, the popular and pro-slavery William Lowndes, came within one vote of winning during the 22 ballots that were cast, but in the end, Taylor eked out a narrow victory. Some historians cite the election and the Missouri Compromise as the first signs of deep and dangerous divisions in the young Union, with one section directly opposing another as if they were enemies.

Supporters of the new Speaker weren’t entirely pleased once he took charge. Where party-member Taylor had been persistently active against slavery and served as House Whip, Speaker Taylor was criticized for pursuing his stated goal of total impartiality, not favoring one party’s agenda over the other. Perhaps he hoped to stem the poison of sectionalism and bring both sides together. Whatever the case, some Southerners distrusted his efforts, and some Northerners felt he had abandoned the fight against slavery.

After replacing Clay, Taylor oversaw the period during which Missouri’s state constitution was reviewed. He served until March 1821, when his reelection bid was lost, due in part to Southerners voting against him for having resisted the spread of slavery. Two years later, Henry Clay returned to the position of Speaker, departing again in 1825. Taylor, who in the interim had supported John Quincy Adams’ winning of the presidency, ran again, and with the support of Adams, he was for a second time elected as Clay’s successor, winning by just two votes. He went on to serve as Speaker until March 1827, when another lost election (by 10 votes) was also attributed in large part to his opposition to slavery. During that same year, he was elected a vice-president of Union College.

Taylor remained in the House of Representatives until 1833, a 20-year span that included service on important committees like Military Affairs, Foreign Relations, Ways and Means, and Elections.

He returned to practicing law in Ballston Spa, and because of a deep dislike for President Andrew Jackson, joined New York’s Whig Party. For several years he actively supported the party’s candidates, and in 1840, Taylor was a successful Whig candidate for the New York State Senate. The following year he suffered a stroke, and resigned in 1842. The next 11 years were spent with his daughter in Cleveland, where he died in September 1854. He was buried in Ballston Spa.

Fellow abolitionist Henry Stanton  – prominent in his own right,  though not as famous as his wife Elizabeth Cady Stanton – said in reminiscence:  “Whoever reads Taylor’s speeches in that troubled period will find them as sound in doctrine, as strong in argument, and as splendid in diction as any of the utterances of the following forty-five years, when the thirteenth amendment [banning slavery] closed the controversy.”

As I mentioned earlier, John Taylor is almost the only New Yorker to serve as Speaker of the House. The other is Theodore M. Pomeroy. The Speaker at the time, Schuyler Colfax, had been elected vice-president on Ulysses S. Grant’s ticket. In order to be available for his swearing in at noon on March 4, 1869, Colfax resigned the speakership at 11 am the day before. Within about an hour, Theodore Pomeroy was sworn in. By law, the 40th Congress ended at noon the following day – as did Pomeroy’s term of approximately 24 hours.

Photos: John W. Taylor (Library of Congress); Taylor historical marker in Charlton (Peter Flass, 2016)

Related Stories

Lawrence Gooley, of Clinton County, is an award-winning author who has hiked, bushwhacked, climbed, bicycled, explored, and canoed in the Adirondack Mountains for 45 years. With a lifetime love of research, writing, and history, he has authored 22 books and more than 200 articles on the region's past, and in 2009 organized the North Country Authors in the Plattsburgh area.

His book Oliver’s War: An Adirondack Rebel Battles the Rockefeller Fortune won the Adirondack Literary Award for Best Book of Nonfiction in 2008. Another title, Terror in the Adirondacks: The True Story of Serial Killer Robert F. Garrow, was a regional best-seller for four years running.

With his partner, Jill Jones, Gooley founded Bloated Toe Enterprises in 2004, which has published 83 titles to date. They also offer editing/proofreading services, web design, and a range of PowerPoint presentations based on Gooley's books.

Bloated Toe’s unusual business model was featured in Publishers Weekly in April 2011. The company also operates an online store to support the work of other regional folks. The North Country Store features more than 100 book titles and 60 CDs and DVDs, along with a variety of other area products.

One Response

  1. Chester Rock says:


Wait! Before you go:

Catch up on all your Adirondack
news, delivered weekly to your inbox