Thursday, September 9, 2021

Adirondack Council: Park has become a ‘wilderness of refuge’

Adirondaack Council reportThe remote, peaceful and serene wilderness areas of the Adirondack Park have become a place of refuge for millions of New Yorkers and others seeking a respite from the troubles of a rapidly changing world, according to the Adirondack Council’s annual State of the Park report.

“The main thrust of the report is that the Adirondacks have become a Wilderness of Refuge for the entire Northeast during a time of great change and turmoil,” said Executive Director Willie Janeway.  “Life is different here because people take it upon themselves to live in harmony with nature in its wildest and most untamed forms.  Those who seek isolation from the crowds of urban life can surely find it.  Those who seek the comfort of a tight-knit, rural community — where everyone knows everyone — can find that as well.  Yet nature remains the dominant force.

“As soon as you get here, you can tell you are in a place that is different from the rest of the world,” Janeway said.  “For that, we owe a debt of gratitude to the generations that preceded us, who created and cared for this park before we were born.  We also owe them our commitment to keep it that way.  For that, we need world-class management and the resources to protect and preserve what is special about this wilderness park.”

At six million acres (9,300 sq. mi.) the Adirondack Park is the largest park in the contiguous United States.  Yellowstone, Yosemite, Grand Canyon and Glacier national parks combined would all fit inside the Adirondack Park.  It is also the world’s largest, intact temperate deciduous forest and home to 87 rare, threatened and endangered species, most of the old growth forest — and 90 percent of the motor-free wilderness — remaining in the Northeast.

State of the Park is a 28-page illustrated report on the actions of local, state and federal officials that helped or harmed the Adirondack Park over the past 12 months.  The report is broken into nearly 100 topic summaries for which officials are granted a thumb up or a thumb down.

State of the Park also includes a Report Card on whether officials accomplished the major priorities of the previous years, and a Spotlight section calling attention to the good deeds of individuals and other not-for-profit organizations.

            Overall, many of the priorities the Council laid out in its 2020 State of the Park were at least partially achieved over the past 12 months, Janeway said.

“Our top priorities were preserving wilderness; new conservation funding; combating acid rain and climate change; stopping the spread of invasive species; helping local communities build their economies; expanding diversity, equity, inclusion and justice among visitors and residents; gaining reforms of the state’s environmental agencies; and defending the NYS Constitution’s guarantee of a ‘forever wild’ Adirondack Forest Preserve.  Some of the gains should be labeled as prospective, since they are plans that still need to be carried out.”

Report Card 

Preserve Wilderness: Thumb Up – New plans were released to address overuse, expand education, build infrastructure, pilot enforcement of wilderness resource capacity limits, hire Forest Rangers, and increase personnel to protect natural resources.

New Conservation Funding: Thumb Up – The state reauthorized a $3-billion Clean Water, Jobs Bond Act for the 2022 ballot, for water, climate, overuse, and the Adirondacks. The Environmental Protection Fund appropriation was a full $300 million. A new $500 million was set aside for clean water.

Combat Climate Change & Acid Rain: Thumb Up – Federal and state governments promoted clean energy and implemented climate actions, rejoined the Paris accord, restored federal protections against acid rain, and enhanced research funding.
Stop Invasive Species: Thumb Up – The state Senate and Assembly approved comprehensive boat inspection legislation to help prevent the spread of aquatic invasive species in Adirondack waters (awaits signature of Governor at press time).

Support More Vibrant Communities: Thumb Up – More funds were approved for planning, smart growth, communications, health care, jobs, housing, and recreational infrastructure.

Expand Park Diversity Equity & Inclusion: Thumb Up – Efforts were expanded to build a more welcoming, inclusive Adirondack Park that celebrates all kinds of diversity.

Approve Environmental Agency Reforms: Thumb Down – The state failed to increase funding, staffing, and oversight of the Department of Environmental Conservation or take action to strengthen the Adirondack Park Agency with updated planning and conservation tools to better incentivize private stewardship and responsible development.

Defend the NYS Constitution: Thumb Up – The Courts and Legislature defended the integrity of the “forever wild” clause of the NYS Constitution and the Legislature secured second passage of the “Environmental Rights Amendment” so voters may approve it in 2021.

Highlights from sections 

Governor: Former Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who resigned in August following a series of investigations into his personal and official conduct, received thumbs up for his approval of funding for clean water projects and support for a road salt task force, the Adirondack Diversity Initiative, a rail/trail project and affordable internet service. He received thumbs down for failing to appoint anyone to the road salt task force, lack of progress on broadband development inside the Park, lack of progress on cell phone coverage expansion Upstate, a leadership vacuum at the Adirondack Park Agency, lack of support for key economic development promises in North Hudson, violating the ‘forever wild’ clause of the NYS Constitution and failing to support key environmental agencies.  The report notes that Gov. Kathy Hochul vowed to end what she called a culture of fear and intimidation in state government. Hochul has been attentive to Adirondack issues, frequently visiting the Park and participating in local events and celebrations. She addressed the Council’s members in July at the Forever Wild Day Celebration, thanking them for helping to protect “God’s favorite place on Earth.”


Both houses won praise for approval of bills to require boat inspections that can stop the spread of invasive species from water to water; passing the Environmental Rights Amendment to the NYS Constitution (on the ballot Nov. 2, 2021); approving a $3-billion environmental bond act, to be on the Nov. 2022 ballot); and, for passing bills to ease broadband service expansion in park communities.  Both houses received a thumb down for missing the opportunity to support an important scientific effort and provide protection to the Adirondack Park’s waters when it failed to budget funding for a comprehensive survey of climate change and acid rain impacts on Adirondack lakes and rivers.  The Senate and Assembly both scored approvals for efforts to improve environmental funding in the budget; and the Assembly received a thumb down for failing to pass a bill that would have offered better protection to wetlands statewide.


The Court of Appeals received a thumb up for its 4-2 decision halting the construction of a network of roads disguised as snowmobile trails through the Adirondack Forest Preserve; a federal court received a thumb up for repealing the Trump administration’s do-nothing replacement for the Clean Power Plan; and a state supreme court decision received a thumbs down for allowing an all-terrain vehicle trail on a road through the Forest Preserve in the Town of Clare.

Attorney General 

Atty. Gen. Leticia James won thumbs up for her lawsuit overturning the Trump administration’s Affordable Clean Energy Rule; for pressing the federal government to declare the Tahawus Railroad to be abandoned by its prior operator so local and state officials can decide its best use; for seeking and reporting the truth in her investigation of the Governor’s conduct; and for securing funding for clean air research via court actions.

Local Government 

Local officials won thumbs up for helping to manage overuse and overcrowding on the Forest Preserve; conducting surveys to determine broadband service needs; creating local septic system inspection laws; creating comprehensive plans; reining-in uncontrolled outdoor gatherings that had damaged the Forest Preserve; using the Adirondack Park as an economic development branding tool; better recreational trails; and achieving Climate Smart Community status.  Individual decisions earned thumbs down for claiming that the Council supported an unconstitutional snowmobile trail proposal and for proposing a map amendment that was likely to pollute a lake in Warren County.

Dept. of Environmental Conservation 

The DEC received thumbs up for working with the Adirondack Mountain Reserve to pioneer a parking reservation system that can help officials control damage to overused areas of the Reserve and the High Peaks Wilderness Area; releasing its force that report recommend actions to give the High Peaks relief from overcrowding; working to promote Leave No Trace outdoor ethics; entering an agreement with Cornell University to help control the spread of all invasive species; for slating a rangers-only academy for 2022 to replace those who have retired; finding previously undiscovered PFAS contamination in a local water supply; prosecuting a moose poacher; helping state agencies cut their carbon output, among other things.  The DEC earned thumbs down for not supporting passage of legislation requiring boat inspections inside the Adirondack Park; for trying to build an unconstitutionally destructive snowmobile trail network on the Adirondack Forest Preserve; and for an incomplete plan to manage the non-conforming structures on the former Debar Park estate.

Adirondack Park Agency 

 The APA won thumbs up for drafting a visitor management plan that could become an official framework for managing overcrowding; approving a well-screen cell tower project; for board member John Ernst’s statement on the importance of controlling shoreline development; and for approving solar power development in appropriate locations.  It received thumbs down for approving two poorly screened cell tower installations; for approving a subdivision plan it had previously earned praise for rejecting; and failing to protect one important wetland from a marina expansion and another from shoreline development.

Federal Government 

President Joe Biden received thumbs up for his reversal of Trump era policy changes that weakened pollution air controls and public health standards; for appointing EPA Admin. Michael Regan and White House Climate Advisor Gina McCarthy; approving the Great American Outdoors Act and other measures to improve funding for acid rain and climate research.  The Army received a thumb up for improving its training planning inside the park, while some Air National Guard units received a thumb down for extreme noise in unsuitable locations, despite discussions promising compliance with agreements to respect homes, communities and wilderness. Maine Congressional Rep. Chellie Pingree received a thumb up for acid rain research money and policy support; but local Rep. Elise Stefanik received a thumb down for maintaining that Joe Biden’s win in the 2020 Presidential election shouldn’t have been certified by Congress, even after the January 6 insurrection that killed both police and protestors.  Federal officials won praise for environmental justice initiatives and for funding to improve broadband service.

Launch of New Campaign  

In the centerspread of State of the Park is an introduction to the Forever Adirondacks Campaign, directed by renowned national wilderness advocate Aaron Mair.  Aaron joined the Adirondack Council in May 2021. Mair will work to bring national attention and federal funding to the protection of Adirondack Park wilderness and clean water, while creating new jobs managing protected landscapes and visitors, as well as pathways for people of color to gain the skills and credentials needed to hold those jobs.

  State of the Park also includes sections on the actions of other state agencies, s “Spotlight” section praising the work of other organizations and individuals, and an awards page listing those who have won special praise from the organization and why.  Finally, the last page of the report sets forth the organization’s priorities for 2022.

            Those include: Preserving wilderness, improving wild land protections; protecting clean water; defending the Constitution’s environmental safeguards; funding science to combat climate change impacts; enhancing funding for the park; supporting communities and fostering diversity, equity, justice and inclusion.

Most Comprehensive Report  

Janeway said that the Adirondack Council’s State of the Park Report was the most detailed and comprehensive report on any park in the United States.

“Our world-class park deserves world-class oversight and management,” said Janeway.  “The Adirondack Council interacts with public officials on every level of government, from the park’s nine village boards to Congress and the White House.  Most importantly, we are non-partisan.  We give credit and find fault with the actions of Republicans and Democrats alike.”

Related Stories

Before John Sheehan joined the Adirondack Council's staff in 1990, he was the managing editor of the Malone Evening Telegram, and previously worked as a journalist for the Troy Record, (Schenectady) Daily Gazette, Watertown Daily Times and Newsday. For the past 20 years, John has been the voice of the Adirondack Council on radio and television, and on the pages of local, regional and national media.

5 Responses

  1. Sunny Day says:

    Here’s a link to copy and paste to read this State of the Park report

  2. louis curth says:

    “Like winds and sunsets, wild things were taken for granted until progress began to do away with them. Now we face the question whether a still higher ‘standard of living’ is worth its cost in things natural, wild, and free.” Aldo Leopold 1948

  3. Tim-Brunswick says:

    What a bunch of baloney….You’d think the Adirondacks was the only wilderness area in the Northeast…..Try looking at how much is classified as “wilderness” and then consider all of the folks who can’t even access it because of that classification. “Northeast”….seriously…what about Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont and Northeast Massachusetts with incredible tracts of wilderness, wildlife, water, etc, etc, etc. not to mention that these areas manage to thrive/survive without all of the heavy-handed rules/regulations that are the rule, rather than exception in this State!

    We certainly are full of ourselves……..

    • JB says:

      I think that you have a valid retort up to a certain point. There are plenty of places throughout the Northeast where one can go and recreate in solitude, other than in the Park. Those places, interestingly enough, are often very easy to access, yet very little travelled compared to the lands in the Park. Often, in recent years, those alternate places have been much more enjoyable places to visit during the exponentially increasingly busy Adirondack tourist season.

      The real virtue that should have been primarily highlighted here, the real unique, rare and vulnerable resource that necessitates the protection of the Park, is not the recreation opportunity that it provides, but the ecosystem that it protects. The other remaining areas of comparably large wilderness in the Northeast, those in Maine and New Hampshire or southern Ontario and Quebec, all continue to be working forests, subject to commercial logging, a human activity that is often not noticeable to the paddler, hiker or hunter, but certainly noticeable to the botanist or ecologist. Vermont and Massachusetts lack contiguously uninhabited tracts that compare in scope those of the Adirondack Park, a scope similarly not noticeable to the paddler, hiker or hunter, but very noticeable to a botanist or an ecologist. Contrarily, there are amazingly vast areas in Maine with virtually no human population, much less populated than anywhere seen in New York State, but those forests are so young that it is often difficult to see for more than a few yards ahead, and they are carefully managed for timber production with aerial pesticide drops to target undesirable species (Gov. Mills just vetoed a bill that would have banned that practice of aerial spraying).

      This is the danger of looking at maps, of reading reports such as this one; the map is not the territory, and no report can be objective–we can only select the subjective viewpoint that we hope will be most representative of those facets of the world which we deem most important. When I see the forest, I look to the trees and the forbs, the graminoid fens and the emergent wetlands. The problem is that just as I hold these aspects to be the most fundamental and essential to the Park, those who disagree cannot elevate the fundamental concerns of others above their own, because we do not believe our concerns to be maps of the territory, but the territories of the map.

  4. Zephyr says:

    “The DEC received thumbs up for working with the Adirondack Mountain Reserve to pioneer a parking reservation system that can help officials control damage to overused areas of the Reserve and the High Peaks Wilderness Area…”

    That statement is false. The trails from the AMR were never surveyed or measured in any scientific manner for “overuse,” and the term has not even been defined. And, trails leading from the AMR parking lot are in far better condition compared to many trails in the High Peaks Wilderness Area. The parking permit system was designed to limit use of a public easement and has been effective at doing so, but for what purpose?

Wait! Before you go:

Catch up on all your Adirondack
news, delivered weekly to your inbox