Thursday, May 16, 2024

New York Hunters Harvested Nearly 210,000 Deer, More Older Bucks Than Ever Before


On May 6, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) Interim Commissioner Sean Mahar announced that during the 2023-24 hunting seasons hunters in New York harvested an estimated 209,781 deer. The 2023-24 deer harvest included more than twice as many older bucks, bucks two-and-a-half years old or older, than were harvested in the early 1990s, and nearly five times as many than were harvested in 1969 when DEC first began monitoring the age structure of New York’s deer herd.

“Nearly 70 percent of the bucks harvested by hunters during the 2023-24 deer hunting seasons were two years or older,” Interim Commissioner Mahar said. “This demonstrates the continued effectiveness of DEC’s Let Young Bucks Go and Watch Them Grow campaign, and the willingness of hunters to voluntarily pass up opportunities at young bucks to improve their future opportunities to harvest older bucks.”

The 2023-24 estimated deer harvest included an estimated 112,224 antlered bucks (i.e., adult males) and an estimated 97,557 antlerless deer (i.e., adult females and fawns of either sex). Statewide, this represents a 3.6 percent decrease in antlered buck harvest and a 15.6 percent decrease in antlerless deer harvest from last season. The decrease in antlerless deer harvest, which is approximately 15 percent lower than the five-year average, is concerning because DEC manages deer populations through actions that encourage harvest of antlerless deer. Harvesting antlerless deer helps ensure deer populations remain in balance with available habitat and do not exceed levels of public acceptance that can lead to increased crop damage, deer-vehicle collisions, and other potentially negative deer-related impacts. Harvesting antlerless deer also helps ensure deer are able meet their nutritional demands for antler development, fawn recruitment, and body growth.

In some areas of the state, especially in Wildlife Management Units (WMUs) 1C, 3M, 3R, 3S, 4J, 6P, 7F, 7H, 7J, 8A, 8C, 8F, 8G, 8H, 8J, 8R, 8S, 9A, and 9F, hunters are not harvesting enough antlerless deer to manage deer populations effectively. The highest deer harvest densities were documented in the Western Finger Lakes region and Central Appalachian Plateau. Hunters harvested more than 10 deer per square mile in WMUs 8H, 8M, 8N, 8R, 8T, 8X, and 9Y, with more than 15 deer harvested per square mile in WMU 8R. In some of these units more antlerless deer need to be harvested to achieve population management objectives.

DEC is evaluating various regulatory and non-regulatory alternatives to increase harvest of antlerless deer during future hunting seasons and encourages all deer hunters in the WMUs to harvest at least one antlerless deer during the upcoming 2024-25 deer hunting season.

Throughout the 2023-24 deer hunting seasons, DEC staff and cooperating taxidermists collected biological samples from 2,713 deer for Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) surveillance. No samples tested positive, and New York State remains CWD-free. DEC reminds hunters to remain vigilant to prevent the introduction of CWD into New York. Additionally, no outbreaks of epizootic hemorrhagic disease were documented in New York’s deer herd in 2023.

Notable Numbers 

  • 15.8 and 0.6 – number of deer taken per square mile in the units with the highest (WMU 8R) and lowest (WMU 5F) harvest density.
  • 67.9 percent – portion of the adult buck harvest that was two-and-a-half years or older statewide, up from 45 percent a decade ago, and 30 percent in the 1990s.
  • 49.9 percent – portion of successful deer hunters that reported their harvest as required by law. This is slightly above the five-year average of 48.6 percent.
  • Approximately 1.7 percent – the precision of DEC’s 2023-24 statewide deer harvest estimate.
  • 13,638 – number of hunter-harvested deer checked by DEC staff in 2023 to determine hunter reporting rate and collect biological data (e.g., age, sex, antler data).
  • 2,713 – deer tested for CWD in 2023-24; none tested positive. DEC has tested more than 65,000 deer for CWD since 2002.

Deer harvest data are gathered from two main sources — harvest reports required within seven days of harvest of all successful deer hunters, and DEC’s examination of harvested deer at meat processors and check stations across the state. Harvest estimates are made by cross-referencing these two data sources and calculating the total harvest from the reporting rate for each zone and tag type.

DEC’s 2023-24 Deer Harvest Summary report provides tables, figures, and maps detailing the deer harvest around the state. Past harvest summaries are also available on DEC’s website. Appendix two of DEC’s Management Plan for White-tailed Deer provides information on how DEC sets deer population objectives throughout the state.

Photo at top: White-tailed buck. Wikimedia Commons photo.

Related Stories

Information attributed to NYSDEC is taken from press releases and news announcements from New York State's Department of Environmental Conservation.

14 Responses

  1. Paul says:

    “67.9 percent – portion of the adult buck harvest that was two-and-a-half years or older statewide, up from 45 percent a decade ago, and 30 percent in the 1990s.”

    This is ridiculous, they have no idea from the data they have on age of deer harvested, certainly not down to a tenth of a percent. I would stop parroting inaccurate information here. At least if the mission for this outlet is to get facts out.

    • Boreas says:

      This is just a DEC report. I don’t see that AA is “parroting” anything. I too would like to see the data reported fact-checked and analyzed by an independent, scientific organization, but unfortunately NY residents seem very comfortable with allowing DEC to manage our game – and subsequently non-game wildife – without question.

      Managing game simply by and for hunting/trapping/fishing is fraught with exacerbating ecological imbalances. “Harvesting” activities should only be part of the calculus, not the primary method of management. But until taxpayers wake up and are appraised of ecological imbalances by an indepentent voice, the staus quo will remain.

    • William says:

      I’ll disagree. 210K deer reported. Over 13K checked by the DEC. This is no different than a political poll or really any sampling method. Sure there is a margin of error but it is simple statistics. You can still believe the numbers lie, totally your right.

      I understand you want an independent, scientific organization to fact check and analyze. What is the basis for stating we need that and who should pay for it? Is it because you, “feel” the DEC has an agenda and therefore is misreporting or the numbers or do you have proof?

  2. JT says:

    With only 50% of hunters reporting their harvests, this increases the error in the final numbers. It’s required by law to report but NYSDEC does not enforce it. With the decline in deer hunters over the years, they cannot afford to lose hunters. They are having a tough time meeting their antlerless deer harvest goals.

  3. Longplayer says:

    “49.9 percent – portion of successful deer hunters that reported their harvest as required by law. ”

    How can they possibly know whether the portion of successful hunters who do not report is 50%, 75% or whatever number if those hunters do not report? Do they catch them on trail cams or with drones footage? lol

    • JT says:

      Deer Check
      The other primary source of deer harvest data is the physical examination (check) of 14,000-17,000 hunter-harvested deer each fall by DEC staff. This deer check occurs predominantly at venison processing facilities and provides biological data about the harvest (e.g., sex and age of the deer, antler measurements, and other data as needed). Additionally, DEC staff record the deer carcass tag #, which is then compared against the hunter harvest reports to determine reporting rates.

      So it is based on a sample, therefore, has some degree of error.

  4. JBF says:

    A lot of critical people here. If the number was 100% correct, how much would it modify DEC’s management or policies? Some people just like to b****. What would you do if you were responsible for the accuracy of the info and the cost of acquiring it.

  5. Longplayer says:

    If we had more wolves we would harvest fewer deer with automobiles.

  6. DONALD says:


Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Wait! Before you go:

Catch up on all your Adirondack
news, delivered weekly to your inbox